Thursday, April 24, 2008

JKR/WB vs. RDR Books

I have been following, with great interest, the lawsuit between JK Rowling/Warner Bros. and RDR Books over the potential publication of Steve Vander Ark's Lexicon book. The book is based on Vander Ark's Harry Potter Lexicon Web site, which I have actually found a very useful tool in my own fanfiction writing endeavors because it gives me information right at the tip of my fingers so that I don't have to look it up in my books. It's saved me a lot of hours of searching, and there are some great articles on it. The problem with the book form is that 90% of the work is lifted directly from Rowling, word for word, and much of it isn't sourced. Rowling and Warner Bros., rightly, sued RDR Books, the Lexicon's publishing company, as soon as the book was completed last fall and the case just went to court last week.

For full coverage of these events, see this great page from The Leaky Cauldron. Much of my analysis is in agreement with Leaky's podcast from last week, with wonderful thoughts from Melissa, John, Sue, and Frak. I love listening to these four every week and their Harry Potter analysis. Melissa and John were present at the trial as well as their friend Samantha, and there were no other representatives from Harry Potter fan Web sites there, so they are the real fan authorities here.


I have a few points to make on this case, and they are as follows:
  • Rowling and Warner Brothers' claims are completely legitimate

  • Fair use does not apply in this situation

  • Vander Ark should be able to publish his own guide to Harry Potter, but it should be of his own creation

  • This book is VERY different from fanfiction

  • The media have done their readers, the Harry Potter community, Rowling/Warner Bros., and Vander Ark a great disservice in their coverage

  • It should come as no surprise to Vander Ark that the fan community is not embracing him anymore, but there is room for healing

  • The best hope for all involved is reconciliation

These basic points are for those who don't want to read my eloquent analysis :) And on to the opinion post ...


My first point is that Rowling has a legitimate claim. Harry Potter is her creation, and she's been extraordinarily lenient in fan responses to her work, for which I am very grateful as it has helped me become a better fiction writer. For the record, fanfiction isn't illegal. Fan Web sites are not illegal. This is because neither of these manifestations of fan response cause the fans to make money. Vander Ark's Web site does not take from JK Rowling's ability to sell her books, but a book form of this Web site for profit is a different story. Rowling announced soon after the publication of Deathly Hallows that she intended to write her own encyclopedia about her world for fans, but that she wanted to do it right so she was not planning on releasing it right away. Personally, I don't think that this gives someone else a license to create a guide like Vander Ark's to her work.

Vander Ark's book is substantially copied material from the Harry Potter books, without sourcing in many cases. One witness in the case counted the book line by line and found that 90% of it is taken directly from the Harry Potter books. IF Vander Ark created a guide to Harry Potter that was in his own words and NOT blatently copied, that would be a different story. Rowling and Warner Bros. are asking him to amend his copy, not abandon the project altogether. I don't think that that is too much to ask. This is the difference between Vander Ark's book and fanfiction -- fanfiction is a creation of an individual author. What I write is completely my own, with the exception that I'm using characters and places and basic plot points from Harry Potter. I'm not making any money off of it, it's a form of fan expression that is legally okay.

One thing that is just terrible to me is that the media has been grating on Rowling for her attitude in this case.  Seriously?  Fair use can't apply here because Vander Ark would be making money.  My dad pointed that out to me, and he would know.  Jo gives to charity, she doesn't just squander her money, and she's provided Vander Ark with so many opportunities here ... and even if she HADN'T, it's still her creation!  This is a thought from John of PotterCast, but really, it's no wonder that the Harry Potter community has rejected Vander Ark in this case.  He's being completely disrespectful and creating a rift that doesn't have to be there.

All that said, there is hope, and that hope is in reconciliation.  The whole world is broken because we are driven by our selfish desires, and Steve Vander Ark is no different from any of us.  Let's not judge as we look at him, but pray for the hope of compromise and forgiveness.  The best road to healing is to recognize when you're doing something wrong.  That's my prayer for Steve.

Keep safe, keep faith.  :)

Saturday, April 5, 2008

Maybe Not Today

I wrote my first post-Deathly Hallows fanfic about a month ago, entitled "Maybe Not Today."  I wanted to wait to blog about it until it had gone through the run-down on the right column of the PhoenixSong front page, but that took quite a while!  Apparently story submissions have slowed down for the site in recent months, but it looks like they will pick up again soon.

"Maybe Not Today" started out as a fluffy short story about the trio and company (including poor Fred) playing in the snow on the first snowy day of the year.  Needless to say, I started writing the story several years ago before Deathly Hallows was released.  I can honestly say that waiting to finish it has made the story what it is today.  I could never have written such a poignant narrative of loss had I not experienced personal losses in the past few years, and I could never have written this story without last April.  My heart still breaks when I remember, and that lingering hurt is what drove this story to completion.

Here is the summary: "Those we love never really leave us, but it takes a while to be able to cope with their absence."

Please do read, and I hope that it brings you comfort if you're going through a loss.

BREAKING: Judge sides with ADV churches

Yes indeed!  It is true!  Judge Bellows has ruled that the Virginia Division Statute is applicable to the case of the eleven churches that voted to break away from TEC in 2006, one of which, of course, is my family's church, The Falls Church.

Response from the Diocese of Virginia: Statement on Property Ruling

What this means is that the judge has determined there is a definitive split in the church.  The next step is another hearing on May 28 to determine constitutionality of the Virginia Division Statute, and then a ruling on the property.  I wrote about this issue some months ago on this blog.  Links to those commentaries:


If you have been following my blog at all, my opinion on this issue should be clear.  This made my day when I read about it yesterday -- praise God for His favor and for granting us mercy in the eyes of Judge Bellows.  My prayer is for His will, not that we will or will not get to keep the property.  Of course, I hope we get to keep the property.  I really want to get married there someday, but the physical building is of no consequence when it comes to the true worship of God.  And still, my ultimate prayer is for reconciliation, not just between The Episcopal Church and those of us who feel estranged because of their reevaluation of scripture, but for all in the body of Christ.

I want to learn more about being Anglican.  I connect so strongly with the mix of traditional and contemporary elements that are present in the Anglican Communion, and I have enjoyed all of the Anglican churches I have attended.  Hopefully I can engage in reading more books about it in the coming months!  Maybe there is an Anglican podcast I can check out.

On another note, I took two finals today, wrote a paper last night, and I have another paper to write before Monday.  The end is in sight.  :)  And then I'll be cruisin' in the Caribbean!

Friday, March 28, 2008

Musings, podcasts, and spring!

There is someone playing guitar outside of my window.  I love it!  He or she is pretty good, too.  It's pleasant background music to go along with writing my last mini ethics paper assignment.  This week we're supposed to analyze our "personal ethical dilemma" from the first assignment and say if our views have changed at all from before.  Mine really haven't.  :)

The flowers are coming out all over campus, and they're beautiful.  I'm going to miss Lexington, but I hear Williamsburg is just as lovely!  I can't believe I'm moving there in pretty much exactly two months.  Absolute craziness.  Ashley and I are working on the flat situation so hopefully that gets finalized soon.  It should be fine.  I also found out today that the masters' project is being cancelled for C&I majors, so that's rather exciting.  I get to save about $800 off tuition!

Okay, so the real reason I'm writing a blog is because I discovered the wonderful art that is podcasting today.  I had listened to a few podcasts before but I hadn't ever really been absorbed by them.  My dad introduced them to me about a year ago.  He's fascinated with them, loves listening to sermons and other theological stuff, which is cool.  I had signed up for a couple of them, ones from our home church and also a Harry Potter one, but hadn't ever really listened to any of them.

Today I decided to listen to a couple while I was stuffing envelopes at Hill House and I really enjoyed them.  I listened to a couple from The Falls Church and a couple from the PotterCast and they were really interesting.  I learned about:
  1. James 1 and hypocrisy: we need to be doers of the Word and not just listeners; the Word shows us who we are and if we hear it and understand but then turn away from it, we're like someone who sees themselves in the mirror and then forgets what they look like
  2. James 2 and judging: placing judgment on others based on how they appear renders our faith ineffective and hurts our witness for the Gospel
  3. PotterCast 131: Interview with J.K. Rowling: mostly stuff about horcruxes and wands
  4. PotterCast 132: Interview with J.K. Rowling part 2: Neville!
  5. PotterCast 138: SnoggCast: well, I'm still in the middle of it, but they're talking about Chapter 7 of Deathly Hallows and it's really interesting!
So podcasts are awesome.  :)

Sunday, March 16, 2008

I need Thee every hour

This quote made my heart ache, so I figure it's a good one.  :)

"My Lord God, I have no idea where I am going.  I do not see the road ahead of me.  I cannot know for certain where it will end.  Nor do I really know myself, and the fact that I think that I am following your will does not mean that I am actually doing so.  But I believe that the desire to please you does in fact please you.  And I hope I have that desire in all that I am doing.  I hope that I will never do anything apart from that desire.  And I know that if I do this you will lead me by the right road though I may know nothing about it.  Therefore I will trust you always though I may seem to be lost and in the shadow of death.  I will not fear, for you are ever wtih me, and you will never leave me to face my perils alone." ~ Thomas Merton

A fitting prayer, for every day.

Saturday, March 8, 2008

Brian Littrell

Rachel and I were listening to my iTunes library today while doing homework and the song "By His Wounds" just so happened to play.  If you don't know, the song is by a group called Glory Revealed, made up of Steven Curtis Chapman, Mac Powell of Third Day, and Brian Littrell (yes, of the Backstreet Boys).  They were all on tour together last year, and I assume that the group was made up when they were on tour.

Rachel and I got to talking about Littrell and his emergence into Christian music, and how we really loved Backstreet Boys when we were in middle school because of Littrell -- he always thanked God first on his CD thank-yous.  Well, Rachel mentioned that some of the songs he had written for the Backstreet Boys were glaringly Christian songs, and I was curious.  She claimed that "The One" from the CD "Millenium" was totally a Christian song, and naturally, she was right.  Observe:

"The One" by Brian Littrell

I guess you were lost when I met you
Still there were tears in your eyes
So out of trust and I knew
No more than mysteries and lies

There you were, wild and free
Reaching out like you needed me
A helping hand to make it right
I am holding you all through the night

I'll be the one (I'll be the one)
Who will make all your sorrows undone
I'll be the light (I'll be the light)
When you feel like there's nowhere to run
I'll be the one
To hold you and make sure that you'll be alright
Cause my fear is gone
And I want to take you from darkness to light

*bridge, chorus*

You need me like I need you
We could share our dreams coming true
I can show you what true love means
Just take my hand, baby please

I'll be the one, I'll be the light
Where you can run to make it alright
I'll be the one, I'll be the light
Where you can run

*repeat*

This makes us really happy.  :)  More evidence of Littrell's awesomeness:

"Welcome Home (You)" by Brian Littrell

When I left home to be who I am
Some people said no way
But I laid it all down, gave everything
In my head rang the words that my Father said
You're never far, I will be where you are
And when you come to me
I will open my arms

And welcome home you
I know you by name
How do you do?
I shine because of you today
So come and sit down
Tell me how you are
You know, son, it's good just to see your face

When I look at you holding my heart
I will give to you all that I am
Son, I know there'll be times
You will feel all alone
I will share with you the words my Father said
You're never far, I will be where you are
And when you come to me
You can bet I will open my arms

*chorus*

Saturday, February 23, 2008

Bibles and basketball

I visited my sister at Georgetown this weekend.  My mom and I went with her to see her roommate's show ("Black Comedy" by the same guy who wrote "Equus"), which was excellent.  It was pretty much hilarious.  After that I went back to Caelah's flat and watched "Pride and Prejudice" (the Keira Knightley version) with her roommates and her.  We went to the Georgetown vs. Cincinnati game today, which was equally excellent.  Mom and Dad have season tickets, so I took Mom's because she decided to stay home.  I had a lot of fun with Dad, and it was cool having good seats in the Verizon Center.  Georgetown won the game by about 20 points, so it was really worthwhile.  :)

I also got to see Langley beat McLean in the District finals today.  That was pretty cool, especially because I know a lot of it has to do with the great coaches.  ;)  So, I watched a lot of live basketball today!

We also went to Saturday night service at TFC.  John spoke tonight on James 3:1-18 and Matthew 12:33-37 on "Taming the Tongue."  He noted that what we say is a mirror of what is in our heart, and our words can bring both life and destruction.  We have to remember that our words have power, especially because we will be held accountable for them.  It's a message I've heard before, but really need to keep hearing on a regular basis.  It's hard for everyone!  James acknowledges this in his book, and the whole point is, controlling our tongue isn't something we can do in our own power.  We need the Holy Spirit and the power of God, through salvation and belief in the lordship of Jesus Christ.  We can do all things through Christ who strengthens us (Phil 4:13) :).

It's back to Lexington tomorrow.  It will be great to see everyone again, but I have to admit, this break was great and exactly what I needed.  These next few weeks will bring changes, but it'll be okay.  It was good to relax and wait and ponder.

Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Another good read

Two posts in 30 minutes, haha...I briefly forgot that I was also going to give a shout out to my friend Kate, who wrote this great piece for The Virginian-Pilot.  She made the front page!  Kate and I are sorority sisters and fellow journalism students.  We've had pretty much every journalism class together, and she's pretty awesome.

Kate got the idea for this piece from our copy editing class.  One of our fellow students is giving up Facebook for Lent and Kate wondered if this was a general trend.  She did some great reporting, so give it a read!

Letter from an Oppressed Minority

In light of the fact that I am on break, I decided to make a more light-hearted post than what I've been writing recently.  Sorry about that.  :)  If you look over at my "Perspectives" blog links, you'll see that the first one is a woman by the name of Anne Kennedy.  She is an ordained Anglican and her blog is great, but her husband, Rev. Matt Kennedy, has written something that I think is just brilliant.  He is a regular contributor to Stand Firm (can also be linked to in the "Perspectives" section) and he wrote this about a year ago.

*DO NOTE* this is a parody.  It's Matt's response to current issues being debated in the Anglican Communion, which you would have to live under a rock to not hear about.  So, he's not being serious.  Just want to make that clear.


My favorite line:
"Jesus spoke from within a primitive culture.  Had he known then what we know today, his opinion would undoubtably more closely resemble by own."

Monday, February 18, 2008

Williamsburg

I just got back from a weekend in Williamsburg with my parents.  We had been planning on going up to Ocean City, but the weather wasn't looking too great, so we decided that a trip to the birthplace of Virginia was a better idea.  ;)  We stayed at the Kingsmill Resort, which is really nice, I highly recommend it.  Besides taking advantage of the spa (massages) and sporting complex, we spent a lot of time reading in our suite and sampling the restaurants.  All good.  Mom, Dad, and I went to the Kings Arms Tavern in Colonial Williamsburg for dinner last night, which was great.  We didn't have a whole lot of time to explore, unfortunately.  Hopefully I'll have much more time to explore over the next year.

I got to go to church with Meghan at Grace Covenant Presbyterian Williamsburg and then have lunch with her afterward at the Caf in the William and Mary Student Commons.  The worship and prayer were both very nice, and everyone seemed friendly.  The pastor spoke on Acts 16:6-40 about how God's mission is to bring the Gospel to everyone, not just to people who have it all together or to people whose life is falling apart.  Paul and Silas bring the Gospel to three very different people in this passage: the widow and merchant Lydia, a slave girl, and a Roman jailer.  Each of them had different needs and different circumstances, but God worked in all of their lives to meet them where they were at.  It reminded me of IV Winter Conference last weekend when John Teter spoke about the fact that God is always at work, even if you can't see it.  He's at work in every person's life.

I love Williamsburg, so I had a great time.  I'm really hoping to be at William and Mary for graduate school...so close to finding out!  Just a few more weeks to wait.  I know that God might have something else planned for me, but I really hope and pray that this is it.  Being there for the weekend really solidified that in my mind.

I also started reading "The Heart of Racial Justice" and "Finding God In Harry Potter."  More updates on those as I get further along throughout the week.  "The Heart of Racial Justice" is about "how soul change leads to social change," i.e. how the Gospel is the antidote for racial and ethnic barriers in the world today.  Christians should be at the forefront of breaking down stereotypes and bringing healing to this broken world.  

"Finding God In Harry Potter" was written by John Granger, an evangelical Christian father of seven who wrote the book after having to eat his words when he told his children they couldn't read the books, then discovered their spiritual content and got hooked himself.  Granger argues that while Rowling was definitely not trying to create a Christian masterpiece, her Christian faith (yes, she's stated in numerous interviews that she is a Christian) does provide a solid and very clear background for her books about Harry, especially evident in her themes of good vs. evil, light vs. darkness, self-sacrifice, redemption, forgiveness, love, community, communal sacrifice, etc.  He says that the reason Harry Potter resonates with so many people is because it is an echo of the Great Story, the story of Jesus Christ.  He also says that it's amazing that the books are so popular in this day and age when people are touting the notion that there is no universal truth or good and evil.  The popularity of Harry Potter means that people still believe in the idea of good and evil and in a story bigger than themselves.  It gives hope for the real story of sacrifice and love and its continuing impact in this world.  I met Granger when he spoke at W&L last fall, and I'm loving the book so far.